Emotions, Social Media, and Politics: a Scoping Reflection

The article “Emotions, social media, and politics: a scoping review” by Ruta Kaskeleviciute, Andrea Nanz, Irina Dietrich, and Jörg Mattes examines how quantitative research has studied emotions in social media and politics. The authors explain that emotions have become increasingly significant in political communication because social media allows citizens and political actors to quickly create, share and respond to emotionally charged political content. Their study aims to provide a systematic overview of how emotions are theoretically approached, defined, measured, and examined in relation to political behaviour. The authors conducted a scoping review of 189 research articles, including 204 empirical studies published between 2013 and 2024. They argue that although emotions are recognised as important in social media and political research, existing studies have important conceptual, theoretical and methodological limitations.

The authors followed the PRISMA guidelines and searched the WEB of Science database for relevant research in communication and political science. The initial search found 657 records. After screening,189 articles were selected for final analysis. Two trained coders examined the studies using categories related to theoretical approaches, conceptualisation of emotions, research design, measurement, methodology, sampling, and research topic. The review also explored how emotions functioned within research designs and which social media platforms and geographical areas were represented in the literature.

One of the main findings was that most of the studies were not clearly grounded in existing theories of emotions.72% of the articles did not specify an emotion or effect theory. The authors also found that emotions were often not clearly defined. Negative emotions received much more attention than positive emotions, with fear and anger being among the most commonly studied. Emotions were also mainly studied as outcomes. In terms of measurement, self-report methods and social media text analysis were most common, while experimental and physiological methods were used much less often.

The review also highlights limitations relating to geographical and platform coverage. The research was concentrated in the United States and Europe. Facebook and Twitter were the most commonly studied platforms, while visual platforms such as Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube received much less attention. Most studies focused on topics such as affective polarisation, COVID-19, misinformation, and political incivility. The authors also mentioned that many studies used non-probability samples, which can make it difficult to generalise the findings to wider populations.

In general, the authors argue that future research should pay more attention to established theories of emotion and clearly define different emotions. They also call for better methods of measuring emotions, more research on positive emotions and greater attention to visual social media platforms such as Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. They suggest that research should also include more diverse countries and populations. This would help future research better understand how emotions influence political communication on social media.

This article is edited by Sana Akhter, based on the paper “Emotions, social media, and politics: a scoping review”. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *